Dismantling the Black-White Achievement Gap Paradigm
Why and How We Need to Focus Instead on Systemic Change
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Report Publish Date: January 1, 2021
This article explores how to improve educational outcomes for Black children by focusing on making necessary systemic changes.
Primary Takeaways
The authors argue that focusing on the achievement gap between Black and White students, as many people have done, does not help improve outcomes for Black students. Instead, they say, this frame sets White children as the ideal, elevates Eurocentric standards, ignores Black children’s competencies, relies on biases and unreliable assessments of children’s learning and abilities, and does not accurately reflect the disparities underlying the gap.
The authors say better strategies are to understand structural racism as the root cause of inequities in education, focus on Black children's strengths and competencies, and use culturally relevant teaching methods to promote academic achievement of Black children.
Overview and Objectives
Researchers, practitioners, and policymakers have focused on eliminating the achievement gap between Black and White children for more than half a century. Even so, Black children’s academic achievement overall has not improved. The authors say it’s time to move away from a model that sets White children as the standard and ignores Black children’s strengths and instead focus on the underlying systemic issues that cause disparities in Black children’s experiences and outcomes.
Hypothesis or Approach
The authors reviewed and now point to existing research to make their points.
How This Influences Change
“Through a culturally relevant strengths-based research, practice, and policy approach, we have identified structures and processes that need to be reimagined and transformed to create systemic change and ensure Black children’s equitable access to experiences and opportunities that lead to school success,” the authors write. “After more than six decades of failed attempts, the time has come for new thinking and action.”
Grant Details
Amount awarded:
$307,000
Awarded on: 05/19/2020
Timeframe: 2020-2022
Grant number: 77424
Location: Boston, MA
About Grantee:
Research: Go Deeper
The challenge of reducing or eliminating the achievement gap between Black and White children in the United States has been a focus of researchers, practitioners, and policymakers for more than half a century. Despite this attention, Black children, on average, continue to underperform relative to White children across traditional educational indicators, including standardized test scores and high school and college graduation rates. Furthermore, these differences have been found as early as the first year of life, with Black children demonstrating lower levels of cognition in infancy compared to White children (e.g., Halle et al., 2009). Why do these Black-White academic achievement gaps persist, despite efforts to eliminate them? We argue to answer this question, we must recognize that previous efforts to address educational disparities by race have overlooked the problems inherent in the achievement gap paradigm and ignored the root cause of the disparities. If we want to improve the educational outcomes of Black children, we need to shift from focusing on the Black-White achievement gap to highlighting the need for systemic change. We need to acknowledge that structural racism is at the root of the educational experiences and outcomes of Black students. Furthermore, it is essential to expand the conceptualization of academic success to move beyond standardized testing metrics and include competencies that are critical for school and life success (i.e., socio-emotional development). As we identify Black children’s developmental competencies, we will be better positioned to provide learning environments that are culturally appropriate and effective. In this paper, we expand upon each of these points and demonstrate how promoting systemic change can enhance the learning outcomes of Black children and better position them for success. Boston University, 2021
Research Team
This study and report was conducted and created by the following people.
- Nicole Gardner-Neblett
- Iheoma U. Iruka
- Marisha Humphries
Research to Explore
Millions Could Lose Medicaid Coverage Due to New Rules
Finding Common Ground Through Healthy Communities
U.S. Adults Agree Broadly on Priorities for Themselves, their Families, and their Communities
Seeking Funding?
See how you can pave the way to a future where health is no longer a privilege, but a right.