“Overall, local news coverage does not center those who are unhoused and their experiences, with a lack of regard for their health, safety, and perspectives.”
—Quin Nelson
Report Publish Date: April 29, 2024
This master's thesis analyzes local TV news coverage of homelessness in Minnesota’s Twin Cities metropolitan area from July 1, 2023, to December 31, 2023, leading up to and immediately following the city of Minneapolis declaring unsheltered homelessness a public health crisis.
The researchers’ content analysis found that local TV news coverage in the Twin Cities showed homelessness as an individual problem, rather than one with structural causes, and did not emphasize solutions. Stories associated homelessness with crime, and reporters rarely turned to those experiencing homelessness as sources. Housing coverage, on the other hand, was more likely to discuss the structural causes of the crisis as well as solutions.
The city of Minneapolis declared a public health crisis concerning unsheltered homelessness on December 7, 2023. The author of this thesis wanted to look at how homelessness is depicted in the media. She wanted to see whether local nightly news stories conveyed information that could help the public better understand homelessness, its causes, and solutions or instead stigmatizes those experiencing homelessness and obscures the issue’s structural roots.
Using content analysis research methods, the author and her research team analyzed stories about housing, homelessness, encampments, and encampment sweeps. From 487 late evening broadcasts, the team used keywords to assemble a sample of 230 stories that mentioned or featured homelessness or housing. This thesis describes the analysis of 20 randomized stories from that sample, which the team used as a pilot to prepare the codebook they later used to code the full sample.
“Overall, local news coverage does not center those who are unhoused and their experiences, with a lack of regard for their health, safety, and perspectives.”
—Quin Nelson
Better coverage of homelessness could lead to better public understanding and more willingness to support systemic solutions. The author suggests that newsrooms find ways to increase reporters’ willingness to speak with unhoused people and give them a voice on local TV.
$4,975,000
Awarded on: 07/01/2022
Timeframe: 2022-2025
Grant number: 79754
Location: Ithaca, NY
On December 7th, 2023, the city of Minneapolis declared unsheltered homelessness a public health crisis. Local TV news coverage continues to serve an important purpose in the Twin Cities metropolitan area, especially in providing the general public with perspectives on relevant social issues. However, the nature of TV news coverage may perpetuate negative perceptions and stigma of those experiencing homelessness, which may reduce the impact of advocacy efforts and policy progress for these individuals. The following study uses content analysis methodology to analyze local TV news coverage in the Twin Cities area that aired from July 1st, 2023 to December 31st, 2023, in order to identify relevant frames, imagery, sourcing, and policy context presented in news stories related to homelessness and housing. Results indicate that TV news stories emphasize consequences of homelessness over causes or solutions. Also emphasized is the association of homelessness with crime that draws police, government officials, property owners, business owners, and politicians as common sources. People currently experiencing homelessness are rarely sourced in contrast with frequent depictions of their environment or living conditions. In comparison, housing coverage demonstrates the ability of TV news to provide structural causes, consequences, and solutions for social issues. Overall, local news coverage does not center those who are unhoused and their experiences, with a lack of regard for their health, safety, and perspectives—in stark contrast to the city’s own declaration.
Quin Nelson, April 2024
This report was conducted and created by the following people.
See how you can pave the way to a future where health is no longer a privilege, but a right.