Skip to main content
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
  • Our Vision
    • Our Vision Overview
    • Why Health Equity
    • Focus Areas
    • Measuring RWJF Progress
  • Grants
    • Grants Overview
    • Active Funding Opportunities
    • Awarded Grants
    • Grantee Stories
    • Grant Process
    • Grantee Resources
  • Insights
    • Insights Overview
    • Blog
    • Our Research
    • Advocacy And Policy
  • About RWJF
    • About RWJF Overview
    • Our Guiding Principles
    • How We Work
    • Impact Investments
    • Staff And Trustees
    • Press Room
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    • Accessibility Statement
Find A Grant
Global Search Dialog
    Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
    • Our Vision
      • Our Vision Overview
      • Why Health Equity
      • Focus Areas
      • Measuring RWJF Progress
    • Grants
      • Grants Overview
      • Active Funding Opportunities
      • Awarded Grants
      • Grantee Stories
      • Grant Process
      • Grantee Resources
    • Insights
      • Insights Overview
      • Blog
      • Our Research
      • Advocacy And Policy
    • About RWJF
      • About RWJF Overview
      • Our Guiding Principles
      • How We Work
      • Impact Investments
      • Staff And Trustees
      • Press Room
      • Careers
      • Contact Us
      • Accessibility Statement
    Find A Grant
    Global Search Dialog

      Taking the Disputes Out of Dispute Resolution: Lessons From State Balance Billing Laws

      Brief Mar-15-2021 | Corlette S, Hoadley J, Kona M, O'Brien M | 1-min read
      1. Insights
      2. Our Research
      3. Taking the Disputes Out of Dispute Resolution: Lessons from State Balance Billing Laws
      Download brief
      A ill man depends on a trustworthy caregiver for assistance.

      An analysis of states’ experiences resolving surprise medical payment disputes between health care providers and insurers offers important lessons for the development of a national independent dispute resolution (IDR) system.

       

      The Issue

      Under a federal law enacted last year, patients are no longer held financially responsible for surprise medical bills, which typically occur when a health care provider who is not in a patient’s insurance network bills for services at a higher rate than an in-network provider. Fourteen states currently operate IDR systems, which use arbitration to resolve payment disputes, yet their structures and dispute outcomes vary. Congress has charged the U.S. Departments of Health & Human Services, Labor, and Treasury with creating a national IDR system to resolve payment disputes between health care providers and insurers before the law takes effect in January 2022.  

       

      Key Findings


       

      Researchers carefully examined four states—Colorado, Washington, Texas and New Jersey—and highlight these key differences.

      • In Colorado and Washington, states that sparingly resort to arbitration, physicians report that the risks of the arbitration process outweigh the benefits. Physicians in Colorado risk paying arbitration costs in full if they lose the dispute.
      • In Texas and New Jersey, states that see an exceptionally high rate of disputes, the arbitration process more often tilts in favor of providers. One factor could be that arbitrators in both states consider the provider’s full billed charge, which is not competitively determined.

       

      Conclusion

      Federal agencies must consider a diversity of IDR approaches and outcomes, as well as various external forces at play in states across the United States, to build a balanced and effective federal structure for IDR.

      About Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms

      The Center on Health Insurance Reforms (CHIR), based at Georgetown University’s McCourt School of Public Policy, is composed of a team of nationally recognized experts on private health insurance and health reform. CHIR works regularly with a multidisciplinary group of faculty and staff dedicated to conducting research on issues related to health policy and health services. CHIR faculty and staff study health insurance underwriting, marketing and products, as well as the complex and developing relationship between state and federal rules governing the health insurance marketplace. CHIR provides policy expertise and technical assistance to federal and state policy-makers, regulators and stakeholders seeking a reformed and sustainable insurance marketplace in which all consumers have access to affordable and adequate coverage.

      Related Content

      Brief
      Dr. Leipsner gives a patient a checkup in the office of Dr. George Leipsner in Maywood, NJ.

      Minimizing Risks to Patients in High-Stakes Provider-Payer Contract Disputes

      While patients have no guarantee that a particular physician or hospital will remain in their insurance company’s network, various policies can protect them in the event of a contract dispute.

      1-min read

      Healthcare Coverage and Access
      • About this Grant

      Subscribe to receive Funding Alerts & more

      Explore the latest in reflection and research from subject matter experts at RWJF and our wide network of partners.

      Email address already subscribed. Please check your inbox to manage your subscriptions.

      Subscribed!

      Thank you. You are now subscribed.

      Tell us what type of content you want to receive.

      Be informed with our twice a month newsletter updating you with relevant news and research around a Culture of Health, as well as the latest funding opportunities.

      Get funded by RWJF: Receive notifications when new funding opportunities are released.

      Receive monthly updates on RWJF-sponsored research that informs many robust health policy debates on Capitol Hill, covering topics like health equity, improving access to quality healthcare, equitable housing, and more.

      Shop talk for researchers. This monthly newsletter covers research news and opportunities from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

      Communications expedite action. Get periodic research and expert insights on the best ways to communicate so we can spread what works.

      Sometimes we have news, announcements or opportunities that don't quite fit the subscription parameters above. If you're interested, we'll send you this information under "There's more...". *If you've indicated you are an EU resident, we will only send these communications if you intentionally check this box.

      Which profession or pursuit best describes you?

      Area(s) Of Interest

      Unsubscribe

      Stop receiving all emails from RWJF

      This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
      • CONTACT RWJF

        50 College Road East
        Princeton, NJ 08540-6614

         

        US Toll Free: (877) 843-7953

        International: +1 (609) 627-6000

      • MANAGE YOUR GRANTS

        MyRWJF Login

        • Facebook
        • LinkedIn
        • YouTube
        • Instagram

      • Our Vision
        • Our Vision Overview
        • Why Health Equity
        • Focus Areas
        • Measuring RWJF Progress
      • Grants
        • Grants Overview
        • Active Funding Opportunities
        • Awarded Grants
        • Grantee Stories
        • Grant Process
        • Grantee Resources
      • Insights
        • Insights Overview
        • Blog
        • Our Research
        • Advocacy And Policy
      • About RWJF
        • About RWJF Overview
        • Our Guiding Principles
        • How We Work
        • Impact Investments
        • Staff And Trustees
        • Press Room
        • Careers
        • Contact Us
        • Accessibility Statement

      ©2001- 

      Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. All Rights Reserved. 

       

      • Manage Email
      • Privacy Statement
      • Terms and Conditions