Marketplace Pulse: Unexpected Insurance Bills to Consumers
Skip to main content
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
  • Our Vision
    • Our Vision Overview
    • Why Health Equity
    • Focus Areas
    • Measuring RWJF Progress
  • Grants
    • Grants Overview
    • Active Funding Opportunities
    • Awarded Grants
    • Grantee Stories
    • Grant Process
    • Grantee Resources
  • Insights
    • Insights Overview
    • Blog
    • Our Research
    • Advocacy And Policy
  • About RWJF
    • About RWJF Overview
    • Our Guiding Principles
    • How We Work
    • Impact Investments
    • Staff And Trustees
    • Newsroom
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
Find A Grant

Marketplace Pulse: Percent of Plans with Out of Network Benefits

Brief Oct-04-2018 | Hempstead K | 3-min read
  1. Insights
  2. Our Research
  3. Marketplace Pulse: Percent of Plans with Out of Network Benefits
Download chart Download table

The Marketplace Pulse series provides expert insights on timely policy topics related to the health insurance marketplaces. The series, authored by RWJF Senior Policy Adviser Katherine Hempstead, analyzes changes in the individual market; shifting carrier trends; nationwide insurance data; and more to help states, researchers, and policymakers better understand the pulse of the marketplace.

The threat to consumers posed by bills from out-of-network (OON) health care providers is an issue that has been gaining prominence lately, with coverage from the media and growing policymaker interest. A number of states have addressed the problem legislatively, and others are considering taking action. There has also been some interest in the issue from the federal government. One of the major settings in which OON billing occurs is in the hospital, particularly the emergency department, where providers may treat a patient but not participate in their insurance company's network. The recent news about the contractual impasse between UnitedHealthcare and Envision, a group of hospital specialists, led UnitedHealthcare to warn publicly that if they couldn't come to terms, many more consumers could face OON bills.

Percent of Plans with Out of Network Benefits Chart from Camille Ahearn, McCabe Message Partners for Marketplace Pulse Oct. 2018

 

With the growing use of managed care plan designs and narrow networks, OON coverage is becoming increasingly rare. This tendency is more pronounced in the fully insured market. In the individual market in particular, there has been a steep decline in the percent of plans that offer OON coverage, from 58 percent in 2015 to 29 percent in 2018. The decline in the small group market has been far less sharp, and probably tracks more closely to what is happening in larger employer plans. Part of the difference in the two segments reflects patterns in carrier participation in the individual market. National commercial carriers, which are more likely to offer broader network plans, exited the individual market in droves in 2016 and 2017, leaving a market that is dominated by Blues and Medicaid-managed care organizations (MMCO). MMCO plans almost always offer closed-network plans, and even many Blues plans have shifted to narrow network offerings in the individual market.

High Deductibles

The share of plans with OON benefits has declined, and so has the comprehensiveness of those OON benefits that are offered. In about 95 percent of individual and small group plans with OON benefits, the deductible must be met before there is any cost-sharing. OON deductibles are generally high, particularly in the individual market, where the median OON deductible is approximately $12,000. In about 30 percent of individual market plans with OON coverage, the deductible is greater than $20,000. The small group market is quite different, with a median deductible of about $6,000 and virtually no deductibles higher than $20,000.

Infinite Maximum Out-of-Pocket

After the deductible is met, cost-sharing usually takes the form of 50 percent co-insurance. This generally continues until the maximum out- of-pocket (MOOP) limit is reached. For ACA plans, the MOOP for in-network coverage is capped at $7,350 for individuals, and at about $14,700 for families. Yet for OON benefits, there is no such limit. In fact, about one-third of individual marketplace plans have no dollar amount for the MOOP, meaning that cost-sharing can continue basically forever once the deductible is reached. For plans that do have dollar limits, they are high. The median for the individual market is close to $19,000. In the small group markets this is much less common, as only 8 percent of plans with OON benefits have no MOOP limit. Median out-of-pocket maximums for plans with dollar limits are about $15,000 in the small group market.  

OON bills are a source of concern to consumers, and a recent study showed that approximately 20 percent of hospital visits among patients with large group coverage resulted in an OON bill. In the case of medical emergencies, the ACA requires that OON care is reimbursed at in-network rates, although depending on state law, providers may still “balance bill” patients. Consumers with plans in the individual and small group markets have a high level of exposure to these charges. Narrow networks increase the likelihood that providers are out of network. Many plans in the small group market and most plans in the individual market do not have any OON coverage at all, and for those that do, the coverage tends to be very minimal, leaving consumers with a lot to lose in the event of an unpleasant surprise.

Related Content

Brief
A concept to illustrate the economic impact of the Covid-19 virus on the restaurant and catering business. Restaurant owner wearing his chefâ  s whites standing in his empty restaurant. Photographed on location in a restaurant on the island of Møn in Denmark.

Marketplace Pulse: Work Requirements in Medicaid and Behavioral Healthcare

Adding work requirements to the Medicaid program would lead to an increase in the number of uninsured and would have negative implications for behavioral healthcare.

5-min read

Healthcare Coverage and Access Policy and Law
Brief
A mother and child in doctor's waiting room.

Marketplace Pulse: Crossing the Bridge to the Marketplace

The percent of Medicaid enrollees projected to lose coverage ranges across states from roughly 10% to 30% after the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency ends.

5-min read

Healthcare Coverage and Access
Brief
Mike Harrington - UMMC Cancer Institute patient

Marketplace Pulse: Medicaid and Marketplace Provider Networks

Access to a network of providers is one of the most fundamental benefits of health insurance, especially in highly regulated markets such as Medicare Advantage and the ACA Marketplace.

6-min read

Healthcare Coverage and Access Policy and Law
View all
SHOW MORE
+

SHARE

Subscribe to receive Funding Alerts & more

Explore the latest in reflection and research from subject matter experts at RWJF and our wide network of partners.

Email address already subscribed. Please check your inbox to manage your subscriptions.

Subscribed!

Thank you. You are now subscribed.

Tell us what type of content you want to receive.

Be informed with our weekly newsletter updating you with relevant news and research around a Culture of Health, as well as the latest funding opportunities.

Get funded by RWJF: Receive notifications when new funding opportunities are released.

Receive monthly updates on RWJF-sponsored research that informs many robust health policy debates on Capitol Hill, covering topics like health equity, improving access to quality healthcare, equitable housing, and more.

Shop talk for researchers. This monthly newsletter covers research news and opportunities from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

Sometimes we have news, announcements or opportunities that don't quite fit the subscription parameters above. If you're interested, we'll send you this information under "There's more...". *If you've indicated you are an EU resident, we will only send these communications if you intentionally check this box.

Yes! I want to tell you more about myself and receive personalized communications in the future.

Area(s) Of Interest

Which profession or pursuit best describes you?

Unsubscribe

Stop receiving all emails from RWJF

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
  • CONTACT RWJF

    50 College Road East

    Princeton, NJ 08540-6614

     

    US Toll Free: (877) 843-7953

    International: +1 (609) 627-6000

  • MANAGE YOUR GRANTS

    MyRWJF Login

    • Twitter link
    • Facebook link
    • LinkedIn link
    • YouTube link

  • Our Vision
    • Our Vision Overview
    • Why Health Equity
    • Focus Areas
    • Measuring RWJF Progress
  • Grants
    • Grants Overview
    • Active Funding Opportunities
    • Awarded Grants
    • Grantee Stories
    • Grant Process
    • Grantee Resources
  • Insights
    • Insights Overview
    • Blog
    • Our Research
    • Advocacy And Policy
  • About RWJF
    • About RWJF Overview
    • Our Guiding Principles
    • How We Work
    • Impact Investments
    • Staff And Trustees
    • Newsroom
    • Careers
    • Contact Us

©2001- 

Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. All Rights Reserved. 

 

  • Manage Email
  • Privacy Statement
  • Terms and Conditions