Participant direction is a movement that has transformed supportive services in many states across the country and many different payment systems.”—James R. Knickman PhD, former Vice President for Research and Evaluation at RWJF
“This approach gives people with disabilities more freedom and responsibility in the same way that all of us want to be in charge of our lives and our choices. It lets the individuals themselves decide how to best use the Medicaid dollars they are already entitled to.”—Tommy G. Thompson, HHS Secretary during the Cash & Counseling demonstration phase
Dates of Program: October 1996 to March 2009
Field of Work: Fostering the development of participant-directed home and community-based services for people with chronic disabilities
Problem Synopsis: Frail older adults and other people with disabilities who receive Medicaid faced many challenges in getting the personal assistance services—help at home with things like bathing, dressing, grooming, preparing meals, and housekeeping—they needed. At the same time, increased spending for long-term care led to the need for more cost-effective personal assistance services.
Synopsis of the Work: Cash and counseling, now called participant direction, is an approach to long-term care personal assistance services in which the government gives people cash allowances to pay for the services and goods they feel would best meet their personal care needs and counseling about managing their services.
The Cash & Counseling national program introduced or expanded participant-directed personal assistance services for frail older adults with disabilities and other people with disabilities in the Medicaid programs of 15 states. The program was a joint venture between the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation in the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Cash & Counseling had a demonstration phase and a replication phase. During the demonstration phase, Arkansas, Florida, and New Jersey developed and implemented programs comparing the cash and counseling model with the traditional agency-directed model for delivering personal-assistance services. Participants were randomly assigned to the treatment group (cash and counseling) or the control group (agency-based personal-assistance services). Mathematica Policy Research, Inc., in Princeton, N.J., conducted a rigorous, independent evaluation of the demonstration program. During the replication phase, 12 states implemented the model developed during the demonstration phase. As the main users of personal assistance services, older adults were a key focus. The RWJF Board of Trustees authorized the program for $18 million.
The 15 states enrolled about 13,500 Medicaid beneficiaries with disabilities in cash and counseling programs. All of the states have continued their participant-directed programs.
The evaluation of the demonstration phase found:
- Cash & Counseling significantly reduced the unmet needs of Medicaid consumers who require personal assistance services.
- Cash & Counseling participants experienced positive health outcomes.
- Cash & Counseling improved quality of life for participants and their caregivers.
- Medicaid personal care costs were somewhat higher under Cash & Counseling, mainly because enrollees received more of the care they were authorized to receive. These increased costs were partially offset by other cost savings in institutional and other long-term care.
- Cash & Counseling need not cost more than traditional Medicaid personal care programs if states carefully design and monitor their programs.
- The Cash & Counseling national program created champions in the federal government for participant-directed services and contributed to the spread of these services through changes in policy, law, and regulation. For example, changes to policies of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 made it easier for states to offer participant-directed programs.
Cash & Counseling improved quality of life for disabled Medicaid participants and their caregivers
- Consumer Choice in Long-Term Care
- Cash & Counseling: Empowering Choice, Improving Health
- How Does Cash and Counseling Affect Costs?
- How Cash and Counseling Affects Informal Caregivers
- "Cash and Counseling" Model a Good Option for Providing Long-Term Care
- Self-Determination for Persons with Developmental Disabilities
- Independent Choices: Enhancing Consumer Direction for People with Disabilities
RWJF Nurse Faculty Scholar Jennifer Bellot writes about losing her grandmother to complications from a medical error.
Learn how The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation is dedicated to building a culture of health in Risa Lavizzo-Mourey's 2014 annual message.
The County Health Rankings & Roadmaps can be put to use right away to help create a culture of health in your community.
RWJF Health & Society Scholar Brendan Saloner on subsidized health insurance's impact on family economics.
America is not getting good value for its health care dollar. These resources explore issues of cost and value of health care.
Developing small community homes as alternatives to nursing homes, this radical, new national model for skilled nursing care returns control...
While the need to address disparities in care is well known, few strategies for reducing disparities have been studied systematically.
Judith Halstead, president of the National League for Nursing, writes about the role of nursing education in realizing a transformed health ...
RWJF Scholar puzzles out why people who do not drink alcohol are at greater risk for premature death than light to moderate drinkers.
List of most current annual reports.
One doctor in Camden, NJ, Jeffrey Brenner, used data to map “hot spots” of health care high-utilizers—one patient had gone to the hospital 1...