Dates of Project: 2002 to 2010
Field of Work: History of the debate over the right to medical treatment in the United States
Problem Synopsis: Unlike citizens of other developed nations, Americans do not have a constitutional or legal right to health care. Yet advocates have established various rights to health care for particular conditions. Despite that history, no one had published research specifically devoted to health care rights and rationing in the United States.
“The history of American health care is a history of rationing, mostly based on ability to pay.”—Beatrix Hoffman, PhD
Synopsis of the Work: Hoffman investigated how medical professionals, patients, government officials, advocates, and the public have talked about a right to medical treatment, and how that debate has affected public policy and medical practice. After receiving an RWJF Investigator Award in 2001, she visited 28 historical archives around the nation, seeking to “find evidence of ordinary Americans’ experiences in the health care system.”
Key Findings and Conclusions: Hoffman published her findings in a book, three articles, and five book chapters. Those findings include:
“Health care for undocumented immigrants has reflected a tension between sympathy for them and a desire to exclude them.”—Beatrix Hoffman, PhD
RWJF Investigator states, "The history of American health care is the history of unequal access."